Accountability-Central.com
Register here.  Forgot your password?  Remember me
HomeAbout The SiteRegistration InformationAdvertising OpportunitiesSpecial Sections
Search

Categories:


Slide10

Accountability Matters

Slide10

NewsAndInfo

NewsAndInfo

 



Click Here to Subscribe to our RSS Feed
 

HOT TOPIC: Executive Compensation

Executive Compensation Introduction

February 2008

How much should a CEO or the top executive officers of a publicly-owned corporation be paid?  What is a “fair” compensation?  Especially when corporations are laying off thousands of workers and outsourcing work to distant lands?  When the middle class is under attack – see CNN Lou Dobbs’ commentary on this?  The issue of exec comp has become a burning question with an array of forces on all sides of the issue.  When the stock market is doing well and “all boats are rising,” the issue is not as much in focus as when companies (or a single firm) is underperforming and the executive compensation is seemingly out of whack.  Out of control. Disproportionate to performance.  Unrelated to reality.  And other battle cries by investor activists, public officials, journalists, advocate organizations, etc.

Consider the case of Home Depot, where the share price fell as the CEO’s pay package rose.  Saying goodbye to the CEO, Mr. Nardelli, cost HD more than $200 million.  Consider the exiting of the Wonderful Wizards of Wall Street, and their departure comp packages – totaling in the hundreds of millions’ of dollars – as the wreckage they’ve left behind (in the form of sub prime disaster loan portfolios) causes real pain on Wall Street, and on Main Street.  We still don’t know the damage they caused with their financial wizardry – but the carnage is felt when home foreclosure rates increase dramatically, as they have over the past year.

So – what is a fair price for the Top Man (and a tiny handful of Top Women)?  You’ll find news, commentary, research and other useful content here in this Hot Topic subsection of Accountability Central, as well as in various content sections and subsections.  (See Corporate Governance, Shareowner Activism, Socially Responsible Investment, and other silos.)

Consider this as you formulate your own positions on the pay issues:

  • Aristotle believed (2400 years ago) that no Citizen of Greece, the first western democracy, should be paid more than seven (7) times that of the lowest earner.
  • The military organizes its service members in two classifications (officer and enlisted ranks), and has a well-structured pay scale (grade, steps in grade etc.) for everyone from privates to general officers and admirals.  Eight pay grades seem to cover one of the largest public institutions in America – the armed services.
  • For many years, especially in regulated industries such as airlines, telephone companies and electric utilities, the military model could often be found. The ratio of pay, say at American Airlines in the regulatory format was $60,000 in 2008 dollars for the lower rank of manager and $600,000 for CEO (10-1) – how quaint!  And consider the disastrous state of airline pay ratios today, as service crumbles and CEO pay soars like the silver-winged jet aircraft!
  • Two decades ago the executive pay system (above) began to change dramatically, and the ratio of highest-to-lowest paid moved from 10-1, or 30-to-1, or 50-to-1 to 300-to-1 or more today.  (Some CEO’s make 1,000-to-one, comparing their pay package to the lowest salaried worker.) 
  • The total pay packages of the top ranked corporate officers are so complex that even board of directors – granting the goodies – cannot understand them.  (Is this good for shareowners, who are represented by the board of directors?)
  • Beginning in January 2007, companies had to report in depth on the total pay packages of the top five (5) highest ranked decision-makers in the corporation.  This is the “CD&A” – the SEC-mandated Compensation Disclosure & Analysis.  For the first time in theory everything is on the table now for inspection, including summaries in easy-to-understand charts.  The second year’s CD&A’s will be reaching shareowners soon.  The SEC’s analysis of the quality of the first year’s disclosure was not a happy time for many of the companies issuing their first CD&A.  Will improvements be made in the Year Two disclosures (covering compensation in 2007)?  Stay Tuned!
  • Finally, many proxy contests soon to become more visible – as shareowners exercise their rights to put non-ordinary business on the shareowner-wide voting ballot – many resolutions will refer directly to or indirectly involve senior executive compensation. 

Enough highlights and commentary – we invite you to follow the often-heated discussions and public debate on executive compensation here in the pages of Accountability Central.

The Editors

 

“…People will be accountable and responsible…”

President Barack Obama – on CEO Comp – February 4, 2009

Comments from Accountability-Central Users

 

 

Submit a Comment

Adding an entry to the guestbook
CAPTCHA image for SPAM prevention 

Latest on Executive Compensation

July 2, 2009 How to Help Directors Increase Oversight of Executive Pay

It's a given by now that the general public, many shareholders, and a number of well-placed government officials agree that there is indeed a problem with executive compensation at publicly traded U.S. companies. What's not as...

AC RSS Feeds, AC RSS, AC Whats New, A/F Commentary & Opinion, CG Commentary & Opinion, Exec Comp Commentary

July 2, 2009 SEC Proposes Measures to Improve Corporate Governance and Enhance Investor Confidence

The Securities and Exchange Commission today voted on three measures that are intended to better inform and empower investors to improve corporate governance and help restore investor confidence. [more]

AC - Billboard, AC RSS Feeds, AC RSS, A/F News, CM News, CG News, GPG News, CFR News, Exec Comp News, Proxy Season 09 News

July 1, 2009 Tomorrow's Problems and Yesterday's Solutions

I do not know sometimes whether I am particularly paranoid or whether others are stupid or, perhaps a bit of both. Either choice is unpleasant. And yet, most of the suggestions by “corporate governance reformers” are either so...[more]

AC - Billboard, AC RSS Feeds, AC RSS, AC Whats New, CG Commentary & Opinion, Robert Monks, Exec Comp Commentary, CFR Commentary, Proxy Season 09 Commentary, SA Commentary & Opinion

July 1, 2009 Government aims for responsibility and visibility on executive pay

Executive compensation became a hot topic earlier this year when it was revealed that AIG was paying their promised executive bonuses in spite of the company's near-demise and subsequent rescue by US taxpayers. Angry quotes and...

AC RSS Feeds, AC RSS, AC Whats New, A/F News, CFR Commentary, Exec Comp Commentary

June 30, 2009 New rules would stop short of CEO pay caps

White House pressing for more transparency, shareholder 'say on pay'

AC RSS Feeds, AC RSS, AC Whats New, A/F News, GPG News, Exec Comp News

June 26, 2009 On Executive Pay, Simpler Is Better

Back in 1990, Michael Jensen wrote a landmark HBR article arguing that "It's Not How Much You Pay CEOs, But How." He wanted boards to adjust pay according to company performance as shown by stock price. V.G. Narayanan's recent...

AC RSS Feeds, AC RSS, Backdating Commentary, Exec Comp Commentary

June 25, 2009 So What Happened to That Talk About Reining in CEO Pay?

The Obama administration has watered down the rules on executive pay into mushy prescriptions that pose no real threat to the Big Boys' windfalls.

AC RSS Feeds, AC RSS, AC Whats New, Exec Comp Commentary, A/F Commentary & Opinion

June 24, 2009 How to pay the CEO?

In the US the average American large-company CEO makes on average 225% more than the average large-company CEO in the other 13 largest industrial countries. The ratio of CEO pay to average employee pay is approximately 300:1....

AC RSS Feeds, AC RSS, AC Whats New, A/F Commentary & Opinion, Exec Comp Commentary

June 24, 2009 Citigroup revamps pay structure

Citigroup is revamping its compensation system – raising salaries and reducing bonuses for top bankers – in an effort to persuade its best performers to stay with the troubled bank.

AC RSS Feeds, AC RSS, AC Whats New, A/F News, Exec Comp News

June 23, 2009 Executive Pay: It's About "How," Not "How Much"

It seems we are moving from an era when "greed was good" to one in which "jealousy is justified"--the executive-compensation regulations being considered now by the government and advocated by shareholder activists aren't very...

AC - Billboard, AC RSS Feeds, AC RSS, AC Whats New, CG Commentary & Opinion, A/F Commentary & Opinion, Exec Comp Commentary
Displaying results 1 to 10 out of 349
<< First < Previous 1-10 11-20 21-30 31-40 41-50 51-60 61-70 Next > Last >>
HOME | ABOUT THE SITE | REGISTRATION INFORMATION | ADVERTISING OPPORTUNITIES | SPECIAL SECTIONS
Published by: Corporate Governance & Accountability Advisors, Inc. Content & Concepts ©2005 by CG&AA, Inc. All rights reserved